Integrating iPad-assisted Learning Strategies in High School Science Education: A Critical Narrative Review from a Theoretical Perspective

J. Venkateswari

Alagappa University College of Education, Alagappa University, Karaikudi, India.

M. Suganthi *

Alagappa University College of Education, Alagappa University, Karaikudi, India.

*Author to whom correspondence should be addressed.


Abstract

Tablet computers, and the iPad in particular, have been introduced into secondary schools on a large scale, often through one-to-one programmes justified by claims that portable, touch-based devices will make science learning more engaging, more authentic and more effective. Empirical support for such claims is uneven, and the theoretical reasons why an iPad-assisted activity should or should not improve learning in high school science have rarely been examined together. This critical narrative review synthesises theoretical and empirical literature on iPad-assisted and closely related tablet-assisted learning strategies for students in the upper years of secondary schooling. Literature was identified through structured searches of education-specific and multidisciplinary scholarly indexes, institutional repositories and citation tracking, and was appraised for relevance, design quality and theoretical contribution. The review examines how cognitive load and multimedia learning theory, embodied cognition, inquiry-based and constructivist perspectives, sociocultural and instrumental accounts, generative learning and motivational theory explain the effects of specific strategies, and how integration frameworks such as technological pedagogical content knowledge and the substitution, augmentation, modification and redefinition model have been used, and misused, to guide practice. Strategy-level evidence is strongest for tablets used as experimental tools with multiple linked representations, for well-guided simulations and augmented visualisations, and for student-led or collaborative uses rather than teacher-led display. Meta-analytic averages are generally positive but highly heterogeneous, and they rest heavily on short, small, non-randomised and media-comparison designs, frequently outside the high school age range. Classroom studies repeatedly show that devices are mostly used to replicate existing practice, that teachers' pedagogical knowledge and beliefs condition outcomes, and that distraction, screen-based reading and unequal access remain unresolved concerns. The review proposes an integrative framework in which device affordances influence learning only through specific cognitive, social and motivational mechanisms that are activated by task design, guidance and teacher knowledge. It concludes that the decisive variable is the learning strategy rather than the device, and identifies priorities for theory-testing, longer-term and context-sensitive research.

Keywords: Mobile learning, tablet computers, secondary science education, cognitive load theory, inquiry-based learning, technological pedagogical content knowledge, augmented reality, technology integration


How to Cite

Venkateswari, J., and M. Suganthi. 2026. “Integrating IPad-Assisted Learning Strategies in High School Science Education: A Critical Narrative Review from a Theoretical Perspective”. Asian Journal of Education and Social Studies 52 (11):884-911. https://doi.org/10.9734/ajess/2026/v52i113489.

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.